I don't see anyone winning my much, but if McCain is trailing in the polls, he needed a victory. Two things stand out in the debate. First, the preconditions to negotiating argument. I can't even comprehend the logic behind McCain's position, I think that was a gaffe. And second, Lehrer telling them to look at each other. Seemed childish and degrading to everyone.
I listened to most of it on the radio driving home from work. I thought both were horrible and no one won.