June 14, 2005

Don’t Call It a "Comeback" for HBO

At some point, it was apparently decided that HBO would replace the departed “Sex and the City” and the on-hiatus-so-often-it-might-as-well-be “Sopranos” with sitcoms- nearly all of which, for some reason, are about Hollywood.

Now I do happen to be a huge fan of both “Curb Your Enthusiasm” (the sitcom of the decade, clearly) and the rapidly improving “Entourage.” But then there was the very weak “Unscripted” (which might have been good, had it had a script), and then “Six Feet Under” decided that it wanted to do Hollywood satire too. I don’t have a problem with Hollywood per se, I just think that there are other topics that HBO could build a high-quality series around, instead of going to the same well over and over again.

The latest entrant is “The Comeback,” a vehicle for “Friends” star Lisa Kudrow that grows entirely from a storyline bandied about but ultimately rejected in ‘Curb’’s first season (remember Larry David and Jason Alexander arguing about whether or not George Costanza was a loser?)- it’s about the former star of a mega-successful sitcom returning with another new show. “The Comeback”’s twist is that it purports to be a reality show itself, allowing it to skewer the reality genre, on top of ripping off both ‘Curb’ and “The Office.”

But the “Comeback”’s biggest mistake is that it matches the awkwardness of those shows, without delivering the laughs to match. Kudrow was always the weakest link on “Friends” anyway (was that “Smelly Cat” song supposed to be funny? I never thought so), and the new show sets the audience up to see the falsity of Hollywood through her eyes- except that we don’t buy it, because she’s even more unpleasant than her antagonists are.

In the end, “The Comeback”’s biggest mistake is that its lead character is immensely, immensely, unlikable- as is the show itself. So it should come as no surprise that Lee Siegel loves it.

Posted by Stephen Silver at June 14, 2005 06:32 PM

Well, there is Deadwood and Carnivale (though that got cancelled) and neither was about Hollywood. And I don't/didn't watch either one.

I'm not impressed with The Comeback either. I'll probably still watch it though, like I do Entourage and Unscripted.

I'm glad they're showing Sopranos on Sundays again. And the first two new episodes of 6FU have been pretty boring. It better be setup for something big.

HBO: The one channel I watch enough of to make any
commentary on the programming. (As I should: I am
paying for it.) :P

Posted by: C at June 15, 2005 12:15 AM

They are so self-obsessed they don't know anything else and that's why they write about their experiences. That's exactly what i was complaining about yesterday.

Posted by: Petitedov at June 15, 2005 12:39 PM

I didnt like THE COMEBACK at first the way I liked CARNIVALE. But COMEBACK is growing on my and Im impressed with Lisa Kudrow, FRIENDS was totally holding her back.

Posted by: Angela at August 30, 2005 02:55 AM
Post a comment

Remember personal info?